Untitled Document Bookstore Questions and Answers Site FAQ Links Bios CURRENTLY UNAVAILABLE


Ask Gordon Pape your question here!

Browse the Archives
1999 - 48 Questions
2000 - 247 Questions
2001 - 267 Questions
2002 - 258 Questions
2003 - 265 Questions
2004 - 255 Questions
2005 - 261 Questions
2006 - 210 Questions
2007 - 230 Questions
2008 - 231 Questions
2009 - 266 Questions
2010 - 148 Questions

Displaying 1 to 10 of 265 Records.
<On-Line Mortgage/RRSP calculator>
<Truth or urban legend? >
<CPP problem>
<Do trailer fees affect advice?>
<Wants to claim tuition fees>
<Wants to use inheritance for RRSP contribution>
<Borrowing to invest>
<Okay, so which fund?>
<Real estate instead of stocks?>
<Interest rate increase>
GOTO PAGE: 1 10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  SHOW ALL 
 
On-Line Mortgage/RRSP calculator
Special note: Last week in response to a question I said I did not know of a good on-line calculator that would help people decide whether to contribute to an RRSP or pay down their mortgage. I’ve now been informed there is a good mortgage vs. RRSP calculator at the following website: http://www.rrsp.org/mtgvsrrsp.htm

Thanks to reader M.F. for providing this information.


Truth or urban legend?
I have heard (whether urban folklore or not?) that you can take your RRSP and give it to a discount broker who will set it up as a sort of “fund”. Then you would borrow that money from the fund and repay it with a market rate interest for a mortgage. Is this true? Are parts of this true? Is it totally false? – P.S., Toronto
I have never heard of this, and it seems to me the concept would be Illegal for a couple of reasons.

First, you cannot borrow money from an RRSP except under two special programs: The Lifelong Learning Plan and the Home Buyers’ Plan. Any other withdrawal would be considered income in your hands and therefore taxable.

Second, an RRSP cannot be used as security for a loan. If this is done, the amount pledged as collateral is supposed to be included in your taxable income for the year. You don’t have to take the money out of the plan but for tax purposes it amounts to the same thing.

Perhaps you are referring to holding a mortgage within your RRSP, which is a perfectly legal practice as long as the terms are not more favourable than a conventional mortgage would offer. You would need a self-directed plan with a financial institution that accepts such mortgages. Note that there are extra costs involved in doing this, so I recommend that any such mortgage be for a minimum of $50,000. There is a full chapter on this subject in my 2003 Buyer’s Guide to RRSPs. – G.P.

CPP problem
I am on Canada Pension and I got a T4 slip in the mail for about $25,000. My question is are they going to want 30% of that in taxes and if so why didn’t they tell me when they gave it to me and I would have paid it then? I am in trouble and need help!! – C.C.
The $25,000 figure sounds high to me. The CPP payment last year for an individual who qualifies for the maximum amount and started collecting at age 65 was about $9,600 for the full year. So you should double-check that the figure on the T4 is correct.

Regardless of the actual amount, all Canada Pension Plan payments are taxable and must be included when you file your 2002 income tax return. The rate of tax you actually pay will be determined by your total income, the marginal tax bracket that puts you in, and your province of residence. In most provinces, you would need more than $30,000 in taxable income before you move into a 30% bracket (approximately).

No tax is normally deducted at source for CPP payments, however you can apply to have tax withheld voluntarily which will eliminate this type of unpleasant surprise in the future. You’ll find details on how to do this at http://www.ccra-adrc.gc.ca/newsroom/factsheets/2000/jan/sac_handout-e.html

As for payments already received, I’m afraid you have no choice but to pay Canada Customs and Revenue. – G.P.

Do trailer fees affect advice?
I have a substantial amount sitting in a money market fund. When I suggest removing putting this money to better use, my broker is reluctant. I'm wondering if there is a trailer fee for brokers on money market funds as opposed to the higher MER funds the company carries and could there be a conflict of interest here? Can you explain how this works? – C.J.
Sounds to me as though your broker has been giving you good advice, depending on what you consider to be “better use”. Certainly you were better off staying in the money fund over the past year as opposed to redeploying the cash into equity funds.

Regarding trailer fees, some money market funds pay a small annual trailer (usually no more than a quarter-point), others pay nothing. By comparison, a typical bond fund pays a 0.5% trailer on a front-end load sale, and half that on a DSC purchase. An equity fund may pay a trailer of 1% on a front-end load sale and half that on a back-end load. However, these figures will vary from one company to another so if you want specifics, ask your broker.

If there is any conflict of interest potential, it would be for the broker to be pushing you out of the money fund and into equity funds that pay higher trailers. It certainly doesn’t seem like that’s the case here. – G.P.

Wants to claim tuition fees
My son is going to college. Can I claim the money for tuition that was paid? He has no income of his own. – T.J.
Yes, you can. A student may transfer any part of both the tuition and education tax credits to a supporting person once the student’s own taxable income is reduced to zero. If your son has no income at all, then he may transfer the full value of the credits to you, to a maximum of $5,000.

Eligible tuition fees include a range of expenses that you might not normally think of as “tuition”, such as admission fees, charges for the use of laboratories and libraries, examination fees, etc. You will find a full list at the Canada Customs and Revenue website at http://www.ccra-adrc.gc.ca/E/pub/tg/p105/p105-e.html#P171_15344

The education tax credit is worth $400 a month for each month that the student is in full-time attendance at a recognized post-secondary institution.

There are some special forms required to claim these credits, or to transfer them. Consult the general tax guide for details. – G.P.

Wants to use inheritance for RRSP contribution
I have a question about unused RRSP contributions. My tax return from last year shows that I can contribute almost $60,000. I have recently received an inheritance and wondered how much of a return I could expect if I made the entire $60,000 contribution? My current salary is $65,000. – G.S.
You can make the entire $60,000 contribution if you wish, but you should spread out the deduction claims over a few years in order to maximize the tax benefit. This is perfectly legal.

For example, claim a large enough deduction for the current year to reduce your taxable income to the lowest bracket (or to zero, if you prefer) and save the rest. If your total income is $65,000, let’s say you have taxable income of $55,000 after various credits and deductions. If you live in Ontario, your marginal tax rate is about 31%. By claiming enough of your RRSP contribution to bring your taxable income down to $31,677, you’ll reduce your marginal rate all the way to 22%. You may decide that’s good enough and keep the remainder of the deduction room for future years. – G.P.

Borrowing to invest
What are your comments on borrowing money to invest in a non-registered plan? What tax implications are there for the money that you borrow? – C.S.
If the money is borrowed for investment purposes, you can usually deduct the interest paid on the loan, under “carrying charges” on the tax return. However, there are some limitations on this, so be sure that the money is invested in qualifying securities like bonds, stocks, mutual funds, and the like. Check with Canada Customs and Revenue if you are unsure.

On the larger issue of the wisdom of borrowing to invest, the technical term for this is “leveraging”. If done successfully, you can significantly enhance your returns because you’re using other people’s money to make profits. However, the risks are significant, as anyone will attest who borrowed heavily to invest back in the late 1990s when stock markets were riding high. Leveraged portfolios have probably incurred heavy losses since then, unless they were very skillfully managed and concentrated on a few high-performance areas such as gold and income trusts.

Anyone can make a strong numbers case for leveraging. However, your personal psychology must be taken into account. People who are uncomfortable with risk should not try this strategy. They are likely to bail out if their securities lose value, locking in their losses in the process. Only investors with a strong stomach, a lot of experience, and patience should consider this approach.

There’s a full chapter on this subject in my book Secrets of Successful Investing, which is now available in a trade paperback edition. It’s available at a discount of 20% off the suggested retail price. See details at Click Here – G.P.

Okay, so which fund?
You suggest a typical investor is better off investing in bond funds, rather than individual bonds. Can you suggest a buy-and-hold bond fund? One that buys quality government bonds and holds on to them, rather than constantly trying to guess where interest rates are going and buying and selling. Such a bond fund would never lose money, ever, but would stagger its purchases (as I do with my GICs) so that every year a percentage of its bond holdings would mature and be replaced at the going rate. Again, is there such a fund? Or does this not make good financial sense? I'm just frustrated at buying bond funds that produce annual returns that are below the five-year GIC rate. – C.O.
I don’t know of any fund that operates in exactly the way you describe. However, I do know of several good bond funds that rarely, if ever, have a down year.

There are two ways to approach bond fund investing. One is to buy units in an index fund, which would come closest to the type of fund you describe. Examples are the CIBC Canadian Short-Term Bond Index Fund and the TD Canadian Bond Index Fund. The CIBC fund has not lost money in any calendar year back to 1996. The TD fund had a small loss of about 2% in 1999. Both funds handily outperformed the average five-year GIC over the period to Jan. 31.

The other option is to choose an actively-managed fund with a low MER (management expense ratio). These are certainly not buy-and-hold funds, but a good manager can add a lot of value to a bond fund’s return. The Phillips, Hager & North Bond Fund receives a top rating in my 2003 Buyer’s Guide to Mutual Funds, but you need $25,000 to get in. The TD Canadian Bond Fund is a less pricey alternative. It shows a five-year average annual compound rate of return of 6.5% to Jan. 31. The average five-year GIC returned 4.6% over the same period.

We will be dealing with bond funds, as well as a wide range of other income-producing securities, in my new newsletter, The Income Investor, which will launch in April. For details on our 40% off charter member special, go to Click Here – G.P.

Real estate instead of stocks?
It seems that buying stock is a gamble unless a person has a lot of money and can get full service from brokerage firms. There is so much in the media these days about real estate being the way to go. Is it worthwhile for the small investor who owns their own home to buy smaller houses, townhouses, etc., and rent them out as a means to acquire wealth? – R.J.
Many people have done well with rental real estate investments, and there are tax advantages to boot. However, you have to know what you’re doing. You need to be able to complete a careful analysis of the carrying costs of a property and its income potential. In some cases, investors are content to break even on the rental side with a view to earning a big capital gain when the property is sold, but that strategy depends on a rising real estate market. I’d prefer to make a reasonable return on the rental income and if there’s a capital gain at the end, so much the better.

Being a landlord is more than a dollars and cents decision, however. You have to be psychologically equipped to handle tenant complaints, deal with problem payers, screen prospective tenants, and more. There’s certainly a lot more work involved than just owning a stock portfolio. – G.P.

Interest rate increase
Congratulations on your site, very informative and to the point for the average middle income Canadian. I find myself extremely perplexed with the announcement last week of higher interest rates. I cannot see how this can benefit people at a time when prices for fuel, insurance, food and more are rising. It just means higher mortgage payments. I'm aware of higher rates being beneficial to my investments, but not for my buying power which is critical in our current national/global situation. What are your views? – W.L.
For the record, I was opposed to higher rates at this time, and still am. Until the U.S. economy starts to strengthen, I believe we should hold our fire. The Canadian economy is already showing signs of slowing down and higher rates won’t help.

That said, there are certain benefits. One, which you have identified, is that low-risk, interest-bearing securities like GICs will be slightly more attractive. Another is a stronger Canadian dollar. Exporters may not like it, but a stronger loonie should reduce the cost of goods imported into this country. If the savings are passed on, it could lead to somewhat lower prices for items like U.S. produce at the supermarket. We can hope so anyway. – G.P.

GOTO PAGE: 1 10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  SHOW ALL 
 

© 1996-2010 Gordon Pape Enterprises Ltd. Please e-mail us for permission before reproducing or redistributing any part of the information contained within.
All material on this site and in any transmissions and publications relating to it is copyright Gordon Pape Enterprises Ltd. and may not be reproduced in whole or in part in any form without written consent. All recommendations are based on information that is believed to be reliable. However, results are not guaranteed and the publishers and distributers of any information and/or recommendations reproduced here or transmitted from this site assume no liability whatsoever for any material losses that may occur. Readers are advised to consult a professional financial advisor before making any investment decisions. Gordon Pape and/or members of his family may hold positions in securities mentioned on this site or in publications associated with it. No compensation for recommending particular securities or financial advisors is solicited or accepted.

Email The Webmaster | Email Customer Service